Get ready for a unique take on baseball's hidden gems!
Unveiling the 2026 All-Underrated Team: A Celebration of Unsung Heroes
In the world of baseball, where rankings and accolades often dominate the spotlight, it's time to shine a light on the players who deserve more attention. Our friends at MLB Network have presented their Top 100 Players list, but I'm here to showcase a different kind of squad - the All-Underrated Team for 2026!
This team is a testament to the players who have flown under the radar, either due to their consistent excellence or their untapped potential. Let's dive into the positions and uncover the stories of these remarkable athletes.
Catcher: Ryan Jeffers, Twins
Catching is an art, and Ryan Jeffers is a master of it. With a challenging position that demands both physical prowess and offensive prowess, Jeffers has quietly excelled. He joins an elite group of catchers with impressive OPS+ numbers, including William Contreras and Will Smith. Jeffers is expected to see more action behind the plate this year, solidifying his place as an underrated star.
First Base: Nolan Schanuel, Angels
Introducing the young phenom, Nolan Schanuel. At just 24, he's already making waves in the big leagues. Despite a rapid promotion, Schanuel has held his own, boasting an OPS+ better than the league average. His elite contact and discipline skills have been praised, and he's on track to become a powerhouse at first base.
Second Base: Xavier Edwards, Marlins
Edwards' journey to the big leagues was not without its twists. Traded twice before his debut, he's now a key piece for the Marlins. While his numbers dipped last season, his disciplined approach at the plate gives hope for consistent results in the future. Defensively, he's a force to be reckoned with, ranking among the best in MLB. Keep an eye on Edwards - he might just be the next Gold Glove winner.
Shortstop: J.P. Crawford, Mariners
Crawford is a prime example of why we need an All-Underrated Team. With an impressive OPS+ over the past five years, he's proven his worth at a premier position. His keen eye and strong on-base percentages make him a valuable asset to the Mariners. Despite winning a Gold Glove in 2020, he's still flying under the radar.
Third Base: Ernie Clement, Blue Jays
Ernie Clement has three strikes against him on paper, but his performance speaks for itself. From breaking records in the postseason to earning a spot on Team USA, Clement has made the most of his opportunities. His high contact rate, speed, and versatility make him a valuable asset at third base. Don't let the accolades distract you - Clement is a true underrated talent.
Left Field: Taylor Ward, Orioles
The acquisition of Taylor Ward by the Orioles raised some eyebrows, but his right-handed power production has been a welcome addition. With an OPS+ better than league average, Ward has proven his worth in the outfield. Congrats to Ward for making the All-Underrated team for the second year in a row! His performance last year was a testament to his talent.
Center Field: Jacob Young, Nationals
Jacob Young might not be known for his offense, but his defensive prowess is unparalleled. With an impressive Outs Above Average stat, he's one of the most eye-catching outfielders in MLB. His highlight-reel catches, including the incredible kick-save, have earned him a spot on this team. Young's defensive achievements are a testament to his underrated status.
Right Field: Matt Wallner, Twins
Matt Wallner's 2025 season was a rollercoaster ride. With an impressive number of extra-base hits, Wallner's underlying metrics reveal a player with quick bat speed and a high barrel percentage. Despite injuries limiting his playing time, his OPS+ is a testament to his potential. Keep an eye on Wallner - he could be a rising star in the making.
Designated Hitter: Dominic Canzone, Mariners
The designated hitter spot is often a challenge to fill, but Dominic Canzone stepped up to the plate. With a solid performance in a limited number of games, Canzone showed his potential against right-handed pitchers. As an Italian-American from Northeast Ohio, I might be a little biased, but Canzone's awesome T-shirt choice solidifies his spot on this team.
Starting Pitcher: Merrill Kelly, Diamondbacks
Merrill Kelly's journey to the Diamondbacks is a testament to perseverance. Drafted three times and released by the Rays, Kelly found success in the Dominican and the Korean Baseball Organization before returning to the States. His impressive record and ERA+ over the past three seasons make him a valuable asset to the Diamondbacks. Kelly's story is a reminder that sometimes the best stories are the ones that fly under the radar.
Relief Pitcher: Danny Coulombe, Free Agent
Danny Coulombe is an excellent example of an underrated reliever. Despite his age and a late-season shoulder injury, Coulombe's numbers are impressive. With an ERA+ and ERA- ranking among the best in MLB, he's a true unsung hero. Coulombe's ability to strike out batters while inducing mishits and groundballs makes him a valuable asset for any team.
This All-Underrated Team is a celebration of the players who deserve more recognition. From catchers to relievers, these athletes have proven their worth, and it's time to give them the spotlight they deserve.
And there you have it - the 2026 All-Underrated Team! A unique and talented group, don't you think?
What do you think of these players? Are there any other underrated stars you'd like to see get some love? Let's discuss in the comments and give these athletes the appreciation they deserve!
